Social Medias in depth pt 1
As someone who is better at communicating via the written word than I am in real life, I have some thoughts about social media. I’ve been on the internet for nearly all of my life. I still remember printing out the ingredient lists for Ultima Online recipes on construction paper because I thought it would look more like a medieval grimoire.1 I’ve been invested into and burned by multiple social media sites (ICQ and AIM chatrooms, random game websites and forums, guild forums, MySpace, then Facebook) and bounced off Xitter a few times before resolving not to use it, ever. But getting away from anything Musk- or Zuck-related leaves a hole in my heart. I do enjoy using social media, I just don’t want to enable the collapse of democracy while I do it.
So, for reasons that are better enumerated by a professional, but include ads, data harvesting, and inevitable enshittification, that leaves us with open source social media (see Cory Doctorow’s post “Bluesky and enshittification” for more).
As it is now, there’s three options that I, a very online but mostly still IRL functional person, know of: Bluesky (AT Protocol), Fediverse (ActivityPub protocol), or Nostr. I applied for a BlueSky account about as early as I could, and follow exactly 2 people I know in real life- one of them is my wife, who I talked into getting one with me, and doesn't post anything, and the other is her friend that doesn't like me that much. That’s disappointing, and not very social. I want it to be better, but it seems like BlueSky (the company) prioritized leeching off ex-Twitter users over basically anything else (see Christine Lemmer-Webber’s “How decentralized is Bluesky really?”).
It managed to grab some of the Xitter uses who maintained a modicum of scruples, but it’s not decentralized, federated, or open source. And even more importantly, it’s expensive to run but also, somehow, not monetized? That ties back to Mr. Doctorow’s post. Personally, I don’t see a long term future with BlueSky.
So let’s try the Fediverse. There are a few people (see the NYT Hard Fork Podcast, “Can we build a better social network?”) getting the message out to the masses. My wife got me listening to the Hard Fork podcast, and they tangentially mentioned the Fediverse a few times before dedicating an episode to it, which ultimately inspired me to host my own Mastodon instance. That… didn’t go so well.
Part two coming soon
Cut me a break, I was in 5th grade↩